Request a CatalogContact Us
 0 Items
Home > Support > Family Life > I have a third grade little girl who is very difficult to homeschool....
 
 
Question: Dear Mom to Mom, I have a third grade little girl who is very difficult to homeschool. She is the oldest of four brothers, so she is already "blessed" with "bossy skills," but it is the arguing that really gets me discouraged. She often interrupts lessons to argue about how I am teaching something. When I ask her to do her homework, she argues. When she has chores, she argues. She argues with her seven year old brother constantly. You get the picture. I am carefully monitoring her relationship with the seven year old, and he tries to get along with her, but she is always mad at him. For consequences, she is writing several sentences daily, and sometimes loses privileges, but the temper and arguing never seem to improve. I humbly admit, I am not a soft spoken quiet mom either, but I try to set a good example most of the time. Any ideas? P.S. I am using your CHC plans for the first time this year, and love them.
Answer:

Dear Mom,

It sounds as if your lovely household is evidence that there are indeed those times when too many mommies can be one too many. Your little girl sounds delightful and she is certainly a joy I am sure as she 'mothers' everyone including you.

I would suggest that you and she sit quietly and have a talk about the challenges that you are seeing in her behavior. Perhaps she can admit to some insights that will explain her nature. It may be time that she work independently in her room or another room of the house. It could be that the distractions that she is creating is more a result of her inability to focus on the work at hand.

I would not give her 'school work' such as writing off sentences as a punishment. This can create a potential challenge down the road. If school work is used as a punishment then it is only a matter of time before all school work is seen as a punishment. Try instead to appeal to her sense of duty and helpfulness. Give her concrete tasks to do that are grown up in nature. Explain that she is afforded this special privilege because she is the oldest and you fairly depend upon her. If she disappoints with argumentative behavior etc. take away the privilege.

Sometimes we moms naturally seem to expect so much more from our first born. It is our desire that we pass along the best of who we are to those we love so much.

Let us pray together a Hail Mary and offer up our prayers for all those that must remember the anniversary of Amish School Shooting. Let us ask that the Lord inhabit their services and fill all present and beyond with the peace that passes all understanding. Amen..

Sending out a prayer,

Rita Munn

   
© 2024 Catholic Heritage Curricula